N※N

Reduce Mahindra Finance; target of Rs 260: Emkay Global Financial

Emkay Global Downgrades Mahindra Finance to 'Reduce' with Rs 260 Target Amid Asset Quality Woes and Growth Challenges

In a recent research note, brokerage firm Emkay Global Financial has issued a cautious outlook on Mahindra & Mahindra Financial Services Limited (MMFS), recommending investors to 'Reduce' their holdings in the stock. The brokerage has set a revised target price of Rs 260 per share, implying a potential downside from current market levels. This downgrade reflects growing concerns over the company's asset quality deterioration, subdued growth prospects, and broader macroeconomic headwinds impacting the non-banking financial company (NBFC) sector. As one of India's leading rural and semi-urban focused financiers, MMFS has been a key player in vehicle financing, but recent quarters have exposed vulnerabilities that could pressure its profitability and market valuation.

Mahindra Finance, a subsidiary of the Mahindra Group, primarily caters to the financing needs of tractors, commercial vehicles, and other rural assets. The company has built a strong network across India's hinterlands, leveraging the group's automotive heritage to capture a significant market share in agricultural and rural lending. However, the brokerage's analysis highlights that MMFS is grappling with persistent challenges in its asset quality, particularly in the wake of economic slowdowns and erratic monsoon patterns that have affected rural incomes. Emkay points out that the company's gross non-performing assets (GNPA) have been on an upward trajectory, signaling higher credit risks in its loan portfolio. This is compounded by elevated provisioning requirements, which are eating into margins and eroding investor confidence.

Delving deeper into the financials, Emkay's report underscores a mixed performance in the recent quarter. While MMFS reported a marginal increase in net interest income (NII), driven by a slight expansion in its loan book, the growth was overshadowed by rising operating expenses and a spike in credit costs. The brokerage estimates that the company's return on assets (RoA) could remain under pressure, potentially hovering around 1.5-2% in the near term, far below pre-pandemic levels. This is attributed to a combination of factors, including higher funding costs amid tightening liquidity in the NBFC space and a slowdown in disbursements. For instance, tractor financing, which forms a core part of MMFS's business, has seen subdued demand due to uneven rainfall and farmer distress in key states like Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Madhya Pradesh.

Emkay's 'Reduce' call is also influenced by valuation metrics. At current prices, the stock is trading at a premium to its historical averages, with a price-to-book (P/B) ratio that the brokerage deems unjustified given the risks. The target price of Rs 260 is derived from a discounted cash flow model, incorporating conservative assumptions on loan growth (projected at 10-12% CAGR over the next two years) and net interest margins (NIMs) expected to compress to around 7-8%. This represents a significant haircut from earlier targets, reflecting Emkay's view that the market has not fully priced in the downside risks. Analysts at the firm argue that while MMFS benefits from its parent group's support and a diversified portfolio, these positives are outweighed by structural issues in the rural economy.

Broader market dynamics play a crucial role in this assessment. The NBFC sector in India has been under scrutiny since the IL&FS crisis in 2018, leading to stricter regulatory oversight and higher borrowing costs. MMFS, like its peers, has faced challenges in accessing cheap funds, with reliance on bank borrowings and commercial papers becoming more expensive. Emkay highlights that the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) recent measures to curb inflation, including repo rate hikes, have further strained the sector's profitability. In this environment, rural-focused lenders like MMFS are particularly vulnerable, as their customer base—comprising small farmers, transporters, and micro-entrepreneurs— is sensitive to interest rate fluctuations and economic cycles.

The report also touches on competitive pressures. With banks encroaching on NBFC turf through aggressive rural lending initiatives, MMFS's market share in key segments like auto and tractor finance could erode. Emkay notes that competitors such as HDFC Bank and State Bank of India have ramped up their presence in semi-urban areas, offering lower rates and faster disbursals. This intensifies the pricing war, potentially forcing MMFS to sacrifice margins to retain customers. Moreover, the shift towards electric vehicles and sustainable farming practices introduces long-term uncertainties, as MMFS's traditional diesel tractor financing model may face obsolescence without swift adaptation.

From a risk perspective, Emkay identifies several key downside triggers. A prolonged monsoon deficit could exacerbate asset quality issues, leading to higher slippages and write-offs. Geopolitical tensions affecting commodity prices, such as fuel and fertilizers, might further strain rural cash flows. On the upside, the brokerage acknowledges potential catalysts like a strong agricultural output in the upcoming season or government stimulus for rural infrastructure, which could boost disbursements. However, these are seen as contingent on external factors, and Emkay advises caution, suggesting that investors wait for clearer signs of recovery before re-entering the stock.

In terms of strategic responses, MMFS has been proactive in some areas. The company has diversified into non-vehicle segments like SME lending and housing finance, aiming to reduce dependency on cyclical rural demand. Recent partnerships with fintech firms for digital collections and risk assessment are steps towards improving efficiency. Emkay commends these initiatives but warns that execution risks remain high, especially in a high-interest-rate regime. The brokerage also praises MMFS's capital adequacy ratio, which stands comfortably above regulatory requirements, providing a buffer against shocks. Nonetheless, the overall tone is bearish, with Emkay forecasting muted earnings growth—earnings per share (EPS) projected to grow at a modest 8-10% annually over FY24-26.

For investors, this downgrade serves as a reminder of the volatility inherent in NBFC stocks, particularly those exposed to rural India. While MMFS has historically delivered robust returns during economic upswings, the current juncture calls for prudence. Emkay recommends that long-term holders trim positions and look for better entry points below Rs 260. Short-term traders might find opportunities in volatility, but the risk-reward skews negatively. Comparatively, peers like Cholamandalam Investment and Finance or Shriram Finance are viewed more favorably by some analysts due to their urban diversification and stronger asset quality metrics.

In conclusion, Emkay Global's 'Reduce' rating on Mahindra Finance encapsulates a narrative of caution amid an uncertain rural recovery. The Rs 260 target underscores the brokerage's belief that the stock's valuation needs to adjust to reflect ongoing challenges. As the Indian economy navigates post-pandemic recovery and inflationary pressures, MMFS's fortunes will hinge on its ability to manage credit risks and capitalize on any rural rebound. Investors would do well to monitor quarterly updates closely, as any improvement in asset quality or disbursement growth could prompt a reassessment. Until then, the path ahead looks bumpy for this rural financing stalwart.

(Word count: 928)

Read the Full moneycontrol.com Article at:
[ https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/stocks/reduce-mahindra-finance-target-of-rs-260-emkay-global-financial-13313257.html ]