• Wed, November 18, 2026
  • Tue, November 17, 2026
  • Mon, November 16, 2026

Community Property vs. Common Law: The Step-Up in Basis Divide

Community property states offer a double step-up in basis for joint assets, reducing capital gains tax more than common law jurisdictions do.

The Mechanics of the "Step-Up in Basis"

To understand the disparity, one must first understand the concept of the "step-up in basis." In the context of capital gains, the "basis" is generally the original purchase price of an asset. When an investor sells an asset for more than its basis, they owe capital gains tax on the profit.

Under federal tax law, when an individual inherits an asset, the basis is typically "stepped up" to the fair market value of the asset at the time of the original owner's death. This is a significant tax advantage, as it effectively wipes away the capital gains tax liability that had accumulated during the deceased person's lifetime. If a person bought a stock for 10 and it was worth100 at their death, the heir inherits it with a basis of 100. If the heir sells it immediately for100, they owe zero in capital gains taxes.

Community Property vs. Common Law

The critical divide arises in how this rule is applied to assets owned jointly by spouses. This depends entirely on whether the couple lived in a community property state or a common law state.

The Community Property Advantage (The "Double Step-Up")

In community property states, assets acquired during the marriage are generally considered owned equally by both spouses, regardless of whose name is on the title. Because of this legal structure, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) allows for a "double step-up in basis."

When one spouse dies in a community property state, the cost basis of the entire joint asset is stepped up to the current market value—not just the half owned by the deceased. For a widow in Texas, this means that if she and her husband held a stock portfolio jointly, she can sell the entire portfolio shortly after his passing and owe nothing in capital gains taxes, as the basis for 100% of the holdings was adjusted upward upon his death.

The Common Law Limitation (The "Single Step-Up")

In contrast, common law states—such as Florida—treat joint assets differently. In these jurisdictions, only the portion of the asset owned by the deceased spouse receives the step-up in basis.

If a couple in Florida owns a portfolio jointly, the surviving spouse is generally seen as already owning their half of the assets. Therefore, only the decedent's 50% share is stepped up to the current market value. The surviving spouse's original 50% share retains its original cost basis from whenever it was first purchased. If the surviving spouse sells the entire portfolio the week after the funeral, they will owe capital gains tax on the growth of their own half of the investment.

Quantifying the Difference: A Hypothetical Scenario

Consider a couple who purchased a diversified stock portfolio for 200,000 twenty years ago. By the time of the husband's death, the portfolio has grown to1,000,000.

  • In Texas (Community Property): The entire 1,000,000 portfolio receives a step-up in basis. The widow&apos;s new basis is1,000,000. She sells the portfolio for 1,000,000 and pays <strong>0 in capital gains tax.
  • In Florida (Common Law): Only the husband's half (500,000) is stepped up to the current value. The widow&apos;s half retains the original basis of100,000. When she sells the portfolio for 1,000,000, she has a taxable gain of400,000 on her half of the assets. Depending on her tax bracket, this could result in a tax bill of tens of thousands of dollars.

The Nine States of Privilege

  1. Arizona
  1. California
  1. Idaho
  1. Louisiana
  1. Nevada
  1. New Mexico
  1. Texas
  1. Washington
  1. Wisconsin
Only nine states currently operate under community property laws that allow for this comprehensive tax advantage. These states include

For residents of the other 41 states, the tax implications of inheriting joint assets are significantly more burdensome. This geographical lottery highlights the importance of strategic estate planning and the role of state residency in wealth preservation. While the federal government sets the broad strokes of tax law, the underlying state property laws determine exactly how those federal rules are applied to a grieving spouse's bank account.


Read the Full 24/7 Wall St Article at:
https://247wallst.com/personal-finance/2026/11/18/a-texas-widow-can-sell-the-couples-entire-stock-portfolio-the-week-after-the-funeral-and-owe-nothing-a-florida-widow-owes-capital-gains-on-half-of-it-and-only-nine-states-give-the-full-step-up/
Like: 👍