Corporates Shift to Commercial Paper Funding Amid Cost Savings

Corporates Increasingly Opting for Commercial Papers Over Bank Loans Amid Cost Advantages, Says SBI Chairman CS Setty

In a recent address, State Bank of India (SBI) Chairman CS Setty highlighted a notable shift in corporate borrowing preferences, with many large companies favoring commercial papers (CPs) over traditional bank loans. This trend, according to Setty, stems primarily from the cost-effectiveness of CPs in the current financial landscape, where interest rates on these short-term instruments have become more attractive compared to bank lending rates. Speaking at a financial event, Setty emphasized that this preference is not indicative of a slowdown in overall credit demand but rather a strategic choice by corporates to optimize their funding costs.

Commercial papers are unsecured, short-term debt instruments issued by corporations to meet immediate working capital needs, typically with maturities ranging from a few days to a year. They are traded in the money market and often carry lower interest rates than bank loans, especially when liquidity is abundant. Setty pointed out that the banking system is currently experiencing high liquidity, with deposits growing faster than credit off-take. This surplus has led to competitive pressures in the money market, driving down CP rates. For instance, top-rated corporates can issue CPs at rates as low as 7-8%, significantly below the benchmark repo rate or the marginal cost of funds-based lending rate (MCLR) that banks use for loans.

The SBI chairman elaborated that this shift is particularly evident among highly rated corporates with strong balance sheets, who find it easier to access the CP market without the regulatory hurdles or collateral requirements associated with bank borrowings. He noted that while bank loans offer longer tenures and structured financing, the immediate cost savings from CPs are compelling in a high-interest-rate environment. This comes at a time when the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has maintained a tight monetary policy to combat inflation, keeping the repo rate steady at 6.5% for several quarters. Setty's comments align with broader market data showing a surge in CP issuances. According to reports, outstanding CPs have risen sharply in recent months, reflecting corporates' pivot away from bank credit for short-term needs.

However, Setty cautioned that this trend poses challenges for banks, including SBI, India's largest lender. With deposits outpacing loan growth, banks are facing margin pressures. He mentioned that SBI's deposit base has expanded robustly, driven by attractive term deposit rates, but credit growth, while healthy at around 14-15% year-on-year, is not keeping pace in certain segments. Corporates' preference for CPs means banks are seeing reduced demand for working capital loans, which traditionally form a significant portion of their corporate lending portfolio. This could lead to underutilization of funds and potentially impact net interest margins (NIMs) if not managed effectively.

To counter this, Setty outlined SBI's strategies, including focusing on retail and small-medium enterprise (SME) lending, where demand remains strong. He stressed the importance of innovation in product offerings, such as digital lending platforms and customized financing solutions, to retain corporate clients. Additionally, SBI is exploring ways to participate more actively in the money market, perhaps by investing in CPs themselves or offering hybrid products that blend the benefits of loans and market instruments.

Setty also touched upon the macroeconomic implications of this shift. In a liquidity-surplus scenario, the increased issuance of CPs could help in better transmission of monetary policy, as market rates adjust more fluidly than bank rates. However, it raises questions about systemic risks, such as rollover risks for CPs if market conditions tighten suddenly. The RBI has been vigilant, imposing guidelines on CP issuances to ensure they do not lead to excessive leverage or liquidity mismatches. Setty expressed optimism that as economic growth accelerates—projected at 7-8% for India in the coming fiscal year—credit demand will broaden, pulling corporates back to bank loans for larger, long-term investments in infrastructure and capacity expansion.

Furthermore, the chairman discussed the evolving dynamics of deposit mobilization. With interest rates on deposits hovering around 6-7% for fixed terms, banks like SBI are competing aggressively to attract household savings. Setty noted that savers are increasingly opting for higher-yielding options, including mutual funds and equities, which adds to the challenge. Yet, he believes that banks' trusted brand and safety net will continue to draw deposits, especially in uncertain times.

In the context of global economic headwinds, such as geopolitical tensions and supply chain disruptions, Setty underscored the resilience of India's banking sector. He pointed to SBI's strong capital adequacy ratios and low non-performing assets (NPAs) as buffers against potential shocks. The bank's gross NPA ratio has improved to below 3%, reflecting effective recovery mechanisms and prudent lending practices.

Looking ahead, Setty advocated for a balanced approach where banks and the money market complement each other rather than compete destructively. He suggested that regulatory tweaks, such as easing norms for banks to issue their own short-term instruments or integrating CP markets more seamlessly with banking channels, could mitigate the current divergence. This would ensure that corporates have access to diverse funding sources while banks maintain healthy growth trajectories.

Overall, Setty's insights paint a picture of a dynamic financial ecosystem where cost efficiency drives borrowing decisions, but long-term stability hinges on adaptive strategies by banks. As India aims for sustained economic expansion, monitoring this trend will be crucial for policymakers and financial institutions alike. The preference for CPs underscores the need for banks to innovate and for regulators to foster an environment that supports both market-based and bank-led financing. This development, while challenging, could ultimately lead to a more efficient allocation of resources in the economy, benefiting corporates, banks, and investors in the long run.

(Word count: 842)

Read the Full moneycontrol.com Article at:
https://www.moneycontrol.com/banking/corporates-favouring-commercial-papers-over-bank-loans-says-sbi-chairman-setty-article-13424270.html